If you watched the All Star game, you realized that Billy Wagner hasn’t just let the Mets down this year, but he has now let the whole National League down, as he blew a save opportunity to close out the game for the National League. This performance got me to thinking, and with a suggestion from a reader, I have decided to write my own midseason report card for the Mets.
Position Players:
First Base: Carlos Delgado-Delgado’s performance is really the tale of two halves in its own right, the early part of the season (April-Mid June) and the late part of the first half (late June-break). Early on, I’d have given Delgado an F, not just because he wasn’t hitting, but because he didn’t hustle on the field, he wasn’t helping the Mets out with his fielding. But, since late June and right on through the All Star break Delgado has almost looked like a different player. He has raised his average to .248 with 17 homeruns and 52 RBI. But it isn’t just his hitting that has been better. He has started to do the little things, like making an effort to field the ball, and taking the extra base when he can. It is an all around hustle that this team has not had and it is good to see it out of a veteran guy. So over all I think Delgado deserves a B-/C+.
Second Base: Luis Castillo-Oh, where do I begin? I think this guy stinks. I do not like his body language or his attitude. I think this signing was a huge waste of money and time. And, let me tell you this, It does not bother me a bit that he will not have his starting job waiting for him. He is a terrible fielder, and maybe that has to do with the fact that he can hardly walk, I think he is a nightmare at the plate, that slap crap hitting annoys me. Also, I just don’t think that he is a good guy. There was a lot of chatter about his relationship with Jose Reyes last year claming that he really isn’t a great influence on him-especially when you consider the mentoring relationship that Reyes had with Jose Valentin. I think this guy is a problem in the club house and an all around lazy guy. Someone also said that part of the reason Castillo is a Met this year is because he and Santana a great friends from their time together in Minnesota, but if that is true, I would say to Santana-you need new friends. Overall grade-F
Third Base: David Wright- David is a hard guy to grade. We all know that this has not been his best season at the plate, yet he leads the team in almost every offensive category hitting .282 with 17 homeruns, 70 RBI and 11 stolen bases. David has struggled this year, and he has not been himself at the plate. He has shown glimpses of coming out of it but has been unable to sustain that for any extended period of time. His fielding has been pretty good, he does have 12 errors, the majority being throwing errors, but they have also been costly errors, especially early on when the Mets were struggling to win games. David is such a likeable guy, even when he is not performing up to the standards he set for himself by what he has done in past years. He says the right thing, does the right thing, answers questions the right way, and an all around good guy. I would take a team full of David Wrights any day. That being said, he is a huge part of this team, and if the Mets are really going to make a run at this, he is going to have to continue to do his part, and work on getting runners home from third with less than two out and work on his strikeouts. Overall grade B+
Short Stop: Jose Reyes-Reyes went into a slump last September and didn’t come out of it until the end of May. But, the good news is he did eventually come out of the slump. He has gotten his average up to .302 with 43 RBI. He has fourth most hits in major league baseball with 119, having hit 10 homeruns, 10 triples, and 23 doubles. He is tied for fifth in the majors with 32 stolen bases. His offensive production is probably one of the factors why the Mets are sitting where they are now. However, Reyes has uncharacteristically struggled with his defense at times. He has already made 12 errors-as a measuring point, he made only 12 errors all last season. He does also still make some mental mistakes but I do think that it is all a process, and when he came up with the Mets we knew he was going to be good, and every year he continues to get better. I think Jose will continue to swing a hot bat and will have a better second half defensively. Over allgrade-B+/A-
Left Field: Obviously this is one position you can’t give a grade to. If you were going to say Endy Chavez, then he scores off the charts solely because of his defense, however, as a whole the position gets an INCOMPLETE because they really are in trouble out there, and what’s to come remains to be seen.
Center Field: Carlos Beltran-Beltran has quietly had a good season. He is hitting .268 with 15 homeruns and 66 RBI, he has suddenly become more aggressive on the base paths and has 15 stolen bases. He started the season out slowly, and I think it had a lot to do with some trepidation coming back after having knee surgery in the off season. His fielding is probably superior to most of the outfielders in the game. While I do think a lot of balls fall in front of him because he plays too deep, rarely do they go over his head, and more often then not he tracks down balls in the gap that almost nobody gets to. Early in the season, I really felt that he and the other Carlos were not doing what they should, and I also thought they were causing a division in the clubhouse. With the departure of Willie Randolph, I think we’ve seen a new Beltran. I loved the fact that he go thrown out of the game against Seattle, I know that he is not typically a demonstrative guy, but it was great to see him stand up for himself and Jerry Manual. Overall grade: B+
Right Field: Again, if Ryan Church were playing out there, he would get an A+, his defense has been superb and his offensive production is something, until just recently, the Mets lineup was really missing. I can’t believe how the Mets front offices screwed this situation up, but I do know they remain optimistic that he may be able to rejoin the team after the all star break. If the Mets can get Church back, and he is able to pick up where he left off, then they might be in good shape out in right field. Overall grade: INCOMPLETE
Catchers: Ramon Castro/Brian Schneider the grade here actually goes to Jerry Manual. I like the way he has played Castro and Schneider. I don’t know if it is the rest that Schneider is getting or the reps that Castro is getting but this quasi platoon seems to be working in the Mets favor. Overall grade B+
Starting Pitching:
Johan Santana he is 8-7 with a 2.84 era, with 114 strikeouts, and has allowed fewer hits than innings pitched. The only concern is that he does give up the long ball, and has given up 14 so far this season. However, Santana has shown that he has the guts to pitch out of trouble, and to pitch in big spots. If Santana actually got some run support, or a good job by the bull pen, Santana could easily be 11-4. However, things haven’t quite worked out that way for Santana. Some fans get on him, suggesting that he isn’t any good, and as I’ve said before I believe that is because they have unreasonable expectations about his performance. For me, has he been as good and I “thought” he was going to be, no-but he has been good. And if you can believe what people say, that he is a second half pitcher, then we have a lot to look forward to. Overall Grade B+/A-
Pedro Martinez-Having Pedro back on the bench is a big plus. I think he brings something to the clubhouse that no other player on the Mets does. That being said, he has been unimpressive since his return. Can Pedro be affective? Can he stay healthy? In his last start he pitched only four innings because of a sore groin and a stiff shoulder. Overall Grade D
Mike Pelfrey- Pelfrey is 8-6 with a 3.64 era. Again, if you were just grading him on his last three starts then the guys deserves an A, but early on he was less than stellar, and was a big contributing factor to the Mets early season woes. However, he never shied away or played the blame game, he kept going out there and working, he has had three good starts and has shown that he can in fact pitch with the big boys. Overall Grade C
John Maine-after hearing about how Maine was dominating spring training, I thought for sure he was in for a big season. Maine is 8-6 with a 3.99 era. He has failed to go deep into the game because he continuously has terribly high pitch counts. We’ve seen more players foul pitches off with Maine on the mound, then I think I’ve ever seen before. He seems to be lacking a real put away pitch and has yet to find that. I think that all of us, Maine included, are disappointed in his season thus far. Overall Grade C-
Oliver Perez-With the addition of new pitching coach Dan Warthen, Oliver has had a chance to reinvent himself. Oliver has an overall record of 6-5 with a 4.44 era, but in the two games he pitched in July he has allowed just one earned run. He has pitched much better in his last three or four starts and seems to have tinkered with his windup and delivery. If Perez keeps this up, he might just get the money he was looking for next year. Perez seems to be either “Good Ollie” and or the “Bad Ollie”, there really isn’t any in between with this guy. Clearly, he too, is a big reason why the Mets’ found themselves in such a hole early on. But, as of late he has been in the middle of the Mets’ resurgence. In the beginning of the season, I would have given him an F, and in his last four starts he deserves an A-. Overall Grade: C+/B-
Bull Pen:
The bullpen has had its fair share of issues so far this season. Since Manual has taken over, I think we’ve seem a mostly better job out of the bullpen.
Scott Schoeneweis- 2-1 with a 2.65 era. In the month of June, this guy was terrible he had a 7.20 era in his 14 appearances and it didn’t seem like he could get anyone out. However, early in the season, he was practically lights out, and he has rebounded stellarly in July, he has allowed no runs in his five appearances. Individual Grade C
Pedro Feliciano- 2-2 with a 2.86 era. Pedro too has struggled; he has given up 34 hits in his 34 2/3 innings of work. Lefties are hitting just 1.72 against Feliciano, but righties are hitting a whopping 3.79 against him. After getting off to a great start, he has really had a rough go of it. Individual Grade C
Duaner Sanchez-I think everyone was happy to have Sanchez back, but he has yet to show that he has returned to his pre-injury self. He is 3-1 with a 3.57 era. He has really struggled, he was pitching to a 6.00 era in May, but was somewhat better in June appearing 13 games and pitching to a 3.60 era. However, in July he has pitched in 7 games, and has only allowed only 1 run. Individual Grade C
Joe Smith-has a 2.97 era. He has had 44 relief appearances so far this season, and has allowed 14 runs on 29 hits in 39 innings of work. He struggled in the early part of the season, and again in June when pretty much the whole bull pen stunk. Again, pretty much like everyone else, he has been much better as of late. Individual Grade B-/C+
I saved my two favorite bull pen guys for last!
Aaron Heilman-Heilman is a head case; I think that every time he goes out to pitch, he keeps thinking to himself, “I’m a starter!” And, maybe he is inside, but not with the Mets. Anyway, he has appeared in 48 games this season and has allowed 29 runs in 50 innings of work. He has a 4.50 era and a 0-3 record. Early on he was getting killed with the long ball, and it seemed like he couldn’t get anyone out. However, when everyone else struggled in June, he was great. I just looked at his numbers and realized that although I think he has been better recently-like since the winning streak, he is still pitching to a 3.52 era in July. From what I understand he has added a third pitch, a slider, that seems to help make his fastball and change up more affective, he has been able to keep the ball down in the zone which has kept the ball in the park. He is a big part of that bullpen whether he realizes it or not. The Mets need for him to get his head on straight if they are going to over take the Phillies. Individual Grade C-
Billy Wagner-has 22 saves in 28 opportunities, his era is 2.31. He has allowed 15 runs (only 10 earned) in 39 innings. What I think about Billy is he is the guy who passes all of his quizzes and then bombs the midterm. What I mean to say is, that Billy got some saves for the Mets when they were easy to get. But, put Billy in a big spot, and he is going to blow it. That has become his reputation, and he has done little to dispel that. I think Mets fans thought he was going to finally get the job done, after years of watching Franco, Benitez, and Looper blow games, Wagner was the missing key. Turns out he took over where the other guys left off. I don’t trust Wagner in a big spot, can’t imagine anyone else does either. Individual Grade F
Bullpen Overall Grade: C
Bench: I am not going to break it down player by player, but I do think the Mets have gotten more out of Endy Chavez, Fernando Tatis, and Damion Easley than anyone thought they might. It is great that they’ve stepped in to be productive.
So, overall I think the Mets get a C, there is no question that they have underperformed. But I do think they have to get some credit for where they are today. The Mets have lucked out and got hot at the right time to pull within a ½ game of the Phillies. I hesitate to get too excited, while the Mets have won 9 in a row, I also know they are capable of playing as terrible as they did in the early first half. I do have more hope for the Mets going into the second half because they have shown that the can and want to win.
Mets Blog
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------